An introduction to the analysis of federalism in political culture

Consequently it attempts to create broad generalizations in order to explain as much activity as possible. They were settled by religious groups that migrated from Europe in an effort to escape persecution and to establish their own ideal communities.

The competition is rarely based on issues since elected officials are immune to electoral pressure and the elites have a consensual position on public policy. Remember, though, that the men who wrote the Constitution did not choose to create a federalist system because they had a great vision of its advantages, but because they had to persuade each state to voluntarily agree to the Constitution, which few—perhaps none—would have done if they had been asked to give up too much of their own political authority; so American federalism was a political compromise, a pragmatic necessity rather than a theoretical vision.

Elements maintaining the federal principle. Finally, governments in the traditionalistic culture are designed to preserve the status quo and benefit elites.

Fiscal and economic issues have declined in importance as Americans became more wealthy over the last half of the twentieth century. In a few very important cases, noncentralization is given support through the constitutionally guaranteed existence of different systems of law in the constituent polities.

Even where there is no formal arrangement, the spirit of federalism tends to infuse a sense of contractual obligation. Unlike traditional political cultures residents do not value unqualified patriotism and an unfettered belief in the virtues of a market economy.

Critiques of Political Culture The study of state and local political cultures has had its share of skeptics over the years. However, the dominant political party typically has a number of intra-party factions that compete with each other for power.

The point has often been made that in a truly federal system the constituent polities must have substantial influence over the formal or informal constitutional -amending process. Stars and Stripes, Justice Dept.

The new political culture is based on a post-industrial, highly mobile society where people consciously choose their residence based on a package of factors that suits their lifestyles. Political science attempts to create theories concerning the causation of political behavior.

Primary among these is the belief that political cultures are nothing more than a synonym for regional diversity in the United States.


Issues take precedence in the moralistic culture. The definitions of, and differences between, unitary, confederal, and federal political systems. In most older European and English-speaking democracies, political authority inheres in the central government, which is constitutionally authorized to determine the limited powers, as well as the geographic boundaries, of subnational associations such as states and regions.

The resulting mixture of laws keeps the administration of justice substantially noncentralized, even in federal courts.

Originally, the federal government required all states to follow the same rules, but in the s states began seeking permission to experiment with devising their own rules for managing the programs, while still using the federal money.

But the EU confederation seems as unstable as any other. Consequently the northern tier of American states is predominantly moralistic, the southern tier is traditionalistic and states in between are individualistic.

Political activities revolve around the community as opposed to individual enrichment and as a consequence, intervention into private activities is acceptable if it furthers a public good. The rarity of confederal systems is highlighted by the difficulty in finding clear examples in the world today.

There are two primary strains of disagreement with political culture as the explanation for why some governments behave differently than others. Education policy, for example, does not necessarily have to be the same across the country, if the people of one state prefer a different educational model than people in another state.

Scholars in this field have attempted to describe the different types of political cultures throughout the country in an effort to understand patterns of political behavior. Elazar claimed there are two layers to political culture in the United States.

The attributes enshrined in a political culture were the consequence of ethnic and religious values of settlers in specific regions of the country.Federalism, mode of political organization that unites separate states or other polities within an overarching political system in such a way as to allow each to maintain its own fundamental political integrity.

Political culture differs from political ideology in that two people can share a political culture but have different ideologies, such as Democrats and Republicans.

The chapter builds upon the assumption established in the previous chapters that the successful operation of federalism can be achieved only if it is rooted in liberal democratic constitutionalism.

To this end the chapter embarks on an initial journey of theoretical clarification before turning to investigate political culture and civil society.

Federalism: An Overview. This chapter introduces the reader to three different types of political structures–-unitary, confederal, and federal–-with an emphasis on explains why the Framers of the U.S.

Constitution adopted a federal system, reviews other federal countries in the world, and surveys arguments for and against federalism. An introduction to the analysis of federalism in political culture Federalism is written into the United States Constitution, but it an introduction to the analysis of federalism in political culture hasn't always worked the same way.

Health Policy and Federalism: An Introduction 3 As we shall see, these threads are quite strong. While federalism is clearly compatible with a wide range of health-care systems, the presence of federal institutions does seem to influence the balance between the public and private sectors in the provision of health care.

An introduction to the analysis of federalism in political culture
Rated 4/5 based on 69 review